Why the MLB Postseason Does Not Use the Extra Inning Runner-on-Second-Base Rule

During the 2020 MLB regular season, the extra inning runner-on-second-base rule was introduced with the intent of shortening games and increasing excitement. However, this rule faced both praise and criticism from fans and players alike. In the context of the MLB postseason, this rule is not utilized because of several reasons, including the importance of the games, the possibility of undeserved advantages, and the preservation of traditional playoff formats.

The Context of the Extra Inning Runner-on-Second-Base Rule

The runner-on-second-base rule in extra innings was adopted in the MLB regular season in 2020. The rule stipulates that in extra innings, the runner on second base remains there at the start of the half-inning, effectively giving the hitting team an automatic runner. Some fans and players appreciated its excitement, while others argued it was an unfair advantage, particularly for teams on the away side who always bat last.

The Reasons for Not Using the Rule in the Postseason

MLB’s rationale for not implementing this rule in the postseason centers around several key factors:

Importance of Playoff Games: In the playoffs, each game is crucial, and teams typically deploy their best players. This results in closer and more exciting games. Unfair Advantage: The rule might give the away team an unfair advantage by starting each half-inning with a runner on second base, potentially leading to biased outcomes in close games. Lopsided Scores: If the team batting first scores early, they could gain a large lead, making the game less competitive and less thrilling for fans and less challenging for trailing teams to come back. Preservation of Tradition: The MLB wants to uphold the traditional format of postseason games, ensuring that every team faces similar challenges and opportunities.

Conclusion and Future Considerations

The decision to eschew the runner-on-second-base rule in the MLB postseason is a testament to the league's commitment to fairness and traditional values. However, as the debate around innovation in baseball continues, it’s possible this rule will be re-evaluated in the future.

While MLB standings and playoff results remain pivotal, the debate around the runner-on-second-base rule highlights the ongoing evolution of baseball rules and strategies. Fans, players, and analysts will continue to weigh in on this and other rule changes, shaping the future of the game.