Who is the Better AEW Signer: CM Punk or Bryan Danielson?

When the news of CM Punk's return to WWE AEW and Bryan Danielson joining the promotion broke, opinions were polarized. Some hailed Punk's return as a seismic shift, while others saw Danielson's arrival as a more strategic signing. Here, we will explore which one deserves the title of the better AEW signer, based on their contributions over the past two years and beyond.

Initial Hype and Legacy

At the height of their debuts, each signing was met with immense anticipation. For Punk, his return to AEW in 2022 was not only personal but also a return to the company that had once given him a platform. Punk's influence and reputation were so significant that fans were eager to see how the Prodigal Son would shape the future of AEW. Similarly, Danielson's entrance into AEW was a massive event for wrestling fans, marking the arrival of one of the greatest grapplers in history.

CM Punk: The Prodigal Son

CM Punk's arrival in AEW was undeniably a momentous event. His seven-year departure from wrestling, not due to injury but personal choice, created a compelling narrative. Punk's return was seen as a sign of the resurgence of an icon, which temporarily elevated AEW to new heights. However, his time in AEW also brought controversy and disappointment. While Punk had some memorable matches and feuds, his on-screen persona often proved disruptive. His antics, including backstage conflicts, detracted from the narrative and tarnished the image of the locker room as a promised land for wrestlers.

Bryan Danielson: The Surefire Success

On the other hand, Bryan Danielson's run in AEW has been nothing short of stellar. His performances have consistently delivered quality matches, captivating the crowd, and setting new benchmarks for in-ring excellence. Danielson's unmatched crowd connection and versatility have allowed him to thrive in various roles, making him a relentless force in the company. His matches with younger and older rivals alike have showcased his adaptability, and his recognition as one of the best talkers in the business is well-deserved.

Legacy Comparison: AEW's Greatest Investments

Comparing the two signings, it's clear that Bryan Danielson has been the more consistent and valuable addition to AEW. While Punk's matches were sensational when successful, his less successful ventures left fans and the company in disappointment. His actions, such as the controversial Brawl Out, have overshadowed his achievements, leading to his unceremonious firing. In contrast, Danielson's career-best run continues to impress, with matches that could be considered career highlights. His contributions to AEW have been immense, and he has not just elevated the company but also honored his legacy as one of the sport's all-time greats.

Conclusion: Conquering Every Metric

In terms of metrics such as match quality, locker room leadership, backstage respect, and staying power, Bryan Danielson stands out as a more significant signing for AEW. Although Punk might have more accolades and a more illustrious track record, Danielson's consistent performance and true value added to the company over a shorter period make him the better signing in the long run. Whether it's through his intense matches, his crowd rapport, or his unmatched professionalism, Bryan Danielson has carved out a unique and enduring legacy in the world of professional wrestling.