The Case for Derek Carr: A Top-10 Quarterback or Not?

When discussing the top-tier quarterbacks in the NFL, Derek Carr is often a name that doesn't make the initial cut. However, is Derek Carr really as far down the list as many suggest, or could he still prove himself among the best?

Debunking the Perception

Many people argue that Derek Carr is merely a serviceable player, not a top-10 quarterback. This perception is partly based on his Pro Bowl appearances, particularly in 2016 and 2017, and his subsequent performances. It's true that in 2016, he was one of only two AFC quarterbacks selected for the Pro Bowl, along with Tyrod Taylor. But does this mean he's merely serviceable?

Pro Bowl Appearances

In 2016, Carr made it to the Pro Bowl despite the unusual circumstances where only two AFC quarterbacks were selected. This wasn't a sign of Carr's exceptional performance, but rather a testament to the strength of the AFC at the time. Similarly, in 2017, Carr's selection was well-deserved given the lack of premier quarterbacks in the Pro Bowl. However, only seven quarterbacks were selected, with most being backups or alternate players.

Evaluating Carr's Performance

To truly evaluate Carr's standing among top-tier quarterbacks, it's essential to look at his overall performance. Current lists generally rate him between 15th and 19th in quarterback rankings, which is a reasonable assessment. While Carr has had some decent seasons, his overall performance suggests he's neither the worst nor the best in the league.

The Top 10 List

Taking a look at the top 10 quarterbacks in the NFL, a clear picture emerges:

These quarterbacks are universally recognized as the elite in the league, setting a high standard that few can match.

The Next Tier

Following the top 10, there's a significant drop-off. The next tier includes:

In this group, Carr is often mentioned, but his performance generally places him at the bottom. This suggests that while he might have some capabilities, he has yet to consistently perform at a high level to place him in the top tier.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, Derek Carr is a top-20 starting quarterback who hasn't yet proven himself as a top-10 player. However, he remains underrated, which means he still has a chance to make a strong case for his inclusion among the elite. If he can demonstrate his ability to engage in high-scoring shootouts alongside quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes, Lamar Jackson, and Russell Wilson, he might just prove the naysayers wrong. Time will tell, but for now, he remains on the cusp of that top tier.