Super Bowl 50 Halftime Show: An Analysis of Past Performances and Current Trends
Mailbag time! I noticed a recurring theme over the past two years: the Super Bowl halftime show is falling short. We keep seeing the same performances, often dominated by black artists attempting to replicate the success of past shows. Can we see a change in the lineup that caters to a broader audience beyond just 14 of any given group?
Visuals and Performances: Comparisons and Critiques
The halftime show of Super Bowl 50 was a visual spectacle with an explosion of colors that reminded me of idol anime. The Vivid Kiss brand was the perfect match for this halftime show, as it harkened back to classic anime aesthetics. Bruno Mars and Beyonce brought the energy at the closing numbers, but Coldplay's selection as the opening act was an odd choice. Martin — the band's lead singer — seemed disoriented, and the performance lacked the spectacle and event atmosphere needed for the Super Bowl stage.
Positive and Negative Aspects of the Halftime Show
On the positive side, the closing number from the halftime show of Super Bowl 50 was impressive. Bruno Mars and Beyonce have a masterful way of working the crowd and maintaining high energy levels. Beyonce's wardrobe included a clear homage to Michael Jackson, reflecting his legacy. However, the appearance of Coldplay seemed misplaced, and their performance lacked the grandeur and spectacle needed for the Super Bowl stage.
Reflections on Spectacle and Audience Engagement
The halftime show often features a round stage with colorful outfits, vivid camerawork, and digital projections. While the inverted umbrellas and through-the-years video montage created an interesting effect, it also called back to the Olympic Games opening ceremony, which is not the ideal format for a Super Bowl halftime show. The show is more about spectacle and event, requiring performances that engage the entire audience, not simply a select few.
Favorite Halftime Shows Compared
Some might argue that the recent Katy Perry performance was the favorite in recent years. Perry's use of the entire space as a creative canvas made the show feel big and unforgettable. She transformed the stadium into a larger-than-life event, creating a memorable experience for all viewers. In contrast, Coldplay's appearance at Super Bowl 50 seemed like a letdown, especially after Beyonce and Bruno Mars lit up the stage.
Conclusion
While the halftime show of Super Bowl 50 had its strengths, particularly in terms of closing numbers and visual aesthetics, it also faced several challenges. The need for a more engaging and spectacular performance remains a pressing issue for future halftime shows. As we look toward future Super Bowls, it is clear that a broader range of artists and formats can help elevate the experience and ensure fan engagement across diverse audiences.