Choosing the Right Formation for Manchester United: 3-5-2 vs 4-3-3
Manchester United fans, it's time to get over the pain and start looking at the differences between the current formation and the alternatives. The 3-5-2 setup that Louis van Gaal has chosen has its advantages, but given recent transfer activity, it's worth considering a shift. Let's break it down for you.
Understanding the 3-5-2 Formation
Van Gaal's team is currently using a 3-5-2 formation, which accommodates multiple players in various roles. This system can be effective, especially considering the fitness of left-back Luke Shaw and the ability of Victor Valdes to regain his fitness post-surgery. However, shifting to another formation might give the team more flexibility and options for improvement.
Rutger van Persie (RVP) and Niggling Injuries
Rutger van Persie's knee injury from last season's Champions League game is a cause for concern. This niggling injury required careful management to avoid missing the World Cup. If he undergoes surgery, considering the 4-3-3 formation could be a viable alternative. In this setup, the focus would shift to defense, allowing Man Utd to address their defensive weaknesses more effectively.
Alternative Formations: 4-3-3
The 4-3-3 formation offers several advantages, especially given the recent transfer activity and the current squad dynamics. Here’s how the team would be structured:
Backline
- De Gea in goal- Shaw, Evans, Jones, Smalling in defense- Rojo as the left-back option if Shaw is unavailable, and Rafael as the right-back
Midfield
- Herrera and Blind as central midfielders- Di Maria as a wing attacker
Attack
- Rooney on the right- Falcao and Mata as attacking midfielders
Main Considerations for the Selection of Formation
De Gea’s capability as a goalkeeper, Shaw’s breakthrough season, and the technical skills and experience of Evans and Jones justify the current defensive setup. Herrera, a key signing, brings versatility to the midfield, capable of playing in a defensive role as well. Di Maria's ability to stretch the play and provide assists makes him a valuable asset, but also poses a challenge in defense. Given these factors, the 4-3-3 formation could be the better choice for the team.
Conclusion
While the 3-5-2 formation has worked for Manchester United in certain situations, the 4-3-3 formation might offer more strategic flexibility and address specific needs brought about by recent transfers. With RVP potentially out for some time, it's essential to consider all options and make the best use of the squad's strengths. Manchester United needs to evolve and adapt to stay competitive in the highly competitive Premier League and Champions League.