AR Caliber for Deer Hunting: M1A .308 or Else?
Introduction to AR Calibers for Deer Hunting
Choosing the right caliber for deer hunting is a critical decision, especially when it comes to an AR rifle. The M1A and the .308 caliber have been popular choices, but they are not always the best options. In this article, we will delve into the pros and cons of these calibers and explore other alternatives.
M1A as an Option for Deer Hunting
The M1A is a battle rifle known for its robust design and reliability. While it can be used for hunting, it might not be the optimal choice for several reasons. Here's why:
Heavy and Uncomfortable
According to many hunters, the M1A is on the heavier side, which can be cumbersome when moving through dense woods or treestands. This additional weight might make it less practical for long hikes or stalking deer. It might be a suitable choice for shooting from a treestand, but the overall weight can be a significant drawback in deer hunting techniques.
Complicated Mounting and Operation
The M1A requires a 150mm mounting rail for scopes, which can be more difficult to secure and maintain zero. Owners often report that securing the scope requires Loctite to avoid loose screws, although the manual explicitly advises against this practice. This added complexity can reduce the rifle's reliability and accuracy.
Trigger and Accuracy Issues
The trigger on the M1A is not as smooth as those on many hunting rifles, leading to potential accuracy problems. Even though it works well for battle situations, it falls short in precision shooting, which is crucial in deer hunting tips and techniques.
Ammunition Concerns
Shooting soft point ammunition in the M1A is discouraged, as the deformed bullet tips can affect accuracy and reliability. Harder, polymer-tipped bullets or specialized ammunition like Fusion are recommended, which can be more expensive and less readily available.
Alternatives to M1A and .308
There are better alternatives available in the market for deer hunting. Let's explore some popular options:
6.5 Grendel
The 6.5 Grendel is a relatively new and potent rifle cartridge, offering excellent performance and accuracy. It is lighter and more effective than the .308, making it an attractive option for hunters seeking a balanced performance.
Remington 750 .308
The Remington 750 in .308 caliber is a reliable and accurate hunting rifle. It is semi-automatic, magazine-fed, and offers quick follow-up shots with a 4-10 round magazine. This rifle strikes a great balance between weight, accuracy, and ease of use.
Mossberg MVP .308
The Mossberg MVP in .308 is a bolt-action rifle that is magazine-fed and lighter than many bolt-action rifles, making it easier to handle for extended periods of hunting. It provides excellent accuracy and is user-friendly, making it a popular choice among hunters.
Conclusion and Recommendations
When it comes to deer hunting with an AR rifle, the choice of caliber is crucial. While the M1A in .308 caliber can be used, it may not be the best option due to its weight, mounting issues, and trigger mechanics. Other calibers like the 6.5 Grendel or alternative hunting rifles like the Remington 750 or Mossberg MVP offer better performance and practicality.
In conclusion, while the M1A can get the job done, it is often more cost-effective and practical to opt for a bolt-action hunting rifle or a light-weight semi-auto like the AR-10. The AR-10, with its Picatinny rail, offers better accuracy and is more lightweight, making it an excellent alternative for deer hunting.